Additionally variety of unusual that off 50+ feedback stating creepy and you mark the practically the only person claiming do it now as better. Precisely why actually make the effort inquiring? posted by Kellydamnit at 3:36 PM on

I chatted it more which includes family of my own and I’m thinking about providing they to another woman i’m not sure better anyway. She is wrestling with many self-confidence problem, from the thing I’ve read, and might perform with only the theory that somebody thinks she’s special

Gaaaaaaah. If you’d like to make somebody happier giving all of them a banjo, find an individual who desires a banjo and present it in their mind. This course of action you must offer some lady, every lady, a banjo is far more about you and your ideas on romance than it is about them, and that’s why it is thus scary. Would you give the banjo to a great male pal? No? failed to think-so. posted by ThePinkSuperhero at 3:41 PM on [42 preferred]

It really looks very fetishistic

This arbitrary cheering up babes with self-esteem dilemmas giving them banjos they can’t bring is actually level 4 about Gein-ometer of creepiness.

Tune in to precisely what the 50+ folks on listed below are telling you. posted by fire&wings at 3:42 PM on [2 preferred]

wow – numerous reviews here on how scary it would be, and you also best answer one that will abide by you? exactly why also upload practical question if you are planning to ignore the overwhelming most the solutions?

it’s really creepy. I would become extremely weirded out to have an anonymous banjo gift. It is very totally possible that she’s going to know it is you which delivered it – even though doesn’t have your own title upon it anywhere, she’ll know that you are the sort of individual do something like this, and it will surely entirely transform this lady belief of you for the tough. you shouldn’t take action. submitted by 5_13_23_42_69_666 at 3:45 PM on [1 favorite]

We talked it over with some family of mine and I’m thinking about giving it to another girl i’m not sure really at all. She’s wrestling with many self-esteem problems, from what I’ve read, and may would in just the idea that a person believes she is unique. What makes this distinctive from that metafilter thread (i cannot recall which) where that girl was actually saying she got roses anonymously for a year, and didn’t find on for a long time it absolutely was this lady companion? I’d similar to it to be a mystery, a pleasurable secret, a grand gesture. Yeah, maybe this kissbrides.com more helpful hints is some self-centered, I’d feel foolish to believe normally, but is here no good results here?

The fact you’re very hung up on providing a banjo to a woman indicates that you are carrying this out with objectification at heart. This really is about their dream of a hot chick playing a banjo under a forest, rather than everything about these female as actual people–which is a significant element of the thing that makes they seems both scary and self-centered, also.

(And seriously? Its shudder-worthy adequate to generate myself wince during the concept of obtaining my personal banjo facing peculiar males. )

I really don’t believe you’re playing the people within thread

Additionally talking as a terrible banjo-player, its a really tough string device to play even although you are curious about they. I think above virtually any more instrument, there’s increased probability that the will merely end up as a costly paperweight, collecting particles in a large part. Though i’d become a little skeeved down about getting private roses for per year, at least there the message is obvious therefore does not warrant a lot of work with the area of the person is valued. posted by PhoBWanKenobi at 3:47 PM on [14 preferred]